The authors of this study, from the May issue of American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, begin by pointing out "diminished muscle protein synthetic response" to food intake can contribute to age-related muscle loss.
In other words, as we get older, protein's anabolic effect on our muscles becomes blunted. Our bodies are less adept at converting the protein we eat into lean muscle mass. For example, we know that as we age we produce fewer endogenous digestive enzymes to properly digest protein. Age also seems to decrease our ability to convert dietary amino acids into functional peptides that can perform metabolic tasks.
Ok, so we're all getting older, blah, blah, blah... Any good news here?
Yes. The kind of protein we eat can make a difference, too. This is good because this is something we have more control over.
The authors here are looking at protein source, rather than our poorly performing digestive systems, for answers. They point out that differences between protein sources, such as digestion absorption kinetics, amino acid composition, or some combination thereof, can affect how much muscle protein synthesis ensues.
So in this study, whey and casein, two common protein sources with two very different absorption rates (casein tends to be slower) were given to a group of 48 males with a mean (that's mathmatical, not tempermental) age of 78.
The group was divided three ways, recieving either 20 grams of whey, 20 grams of casein, or 20 grams of casein hydrolysate. Proteins were tagged with a phenylanine tracer so that absorption and amino acid kinetics could be accurately observed.
How did things turn out?
Whey protein outperformed the rest when it came to speed and peak of absorption. And whey protein demonstrated the best postprandial mixed muscle protein fractional synthetic rates - aka muscle building.
Bonus: whey protein is naturally higher in leucine, which simultaneously promotes fat loss and support lean muscle growth.
The authors conclude:
"Whey protein stimulates postprandial muscle protein accretion more effectively than do casein and casein hydrolysate in older men. This effect is attributed to a combination of whey's faster digestion and absorption kinetics and higher leucine content."
Whey protein was the clear winner when it comes to muscle synthesis in older men.
Wait. Read that conclusion again.
The authors attribute the superior muscle protein synthesis of whey protein to two factors:
1. Whey's faster digestion and absorption kinetics
2. Higher leucine content
Sound familiar?
Aminogen was shown in a published clinical study to:
1. Triple the rate of whey protein absorption
2. Increase levels of branched-chain amino acids like leucine by 250 percent
Ah, interesting.
By the way, a friendly reminder not to throw the baby out with the bathwater. While whey may be where it's at for fast muscle synthesis, casein actually has remarkable properties of its own. It moves more slowly through the digestive tract and therefore can be ideal when you want a steady (steadier) influx of amino acids, like overnight. Casein glycomacropeptides promote healthy gastrointestinal bacteria and may support immune and cardiovascular health as well.
The takeaway here is to know your goals when selecting your protein source. And when that includes building and maintaining lean muscle, whey protein has been shown to produce more immediate muscle protein synthesis. Given that the published clinical on Aminogen shows an increased absorption rate (triple!) and increased amino acid levels over whey protein alone, you might do well to keep the patented enzyme in mind as well!
Extra Credit:
Better Results: Whey Protein or Free Form Amino Acids?
Five Ways to Lose Muscle Fast
Recent Comments